Data Exhaust and Personal Data: Learning from Consumer Products to Enhance Enterprise UX
Summary
In this talk, Sam, drawing from his ethnographic background and work with Microsoft, discusses the evolution and challenges of enterprise UX design. He references Shoshana Zuboff’s 1980s study of insurance clerks chained to desks by digitization, showing how technology can alienate and isolate workers by reducing social interaction. Sam emphasizes the unique sociological aspects of workplaces, where users resist tools they dislike and management styles (Theory X vs. Theory Y) deeply impact adoption and experience. Jonathan Gruden’s 25-year-old concerns about digital calendar adoption illustrate the tension between buyers and users in enterprise software. Sam stresses the importance of designing for users’ real work contexts and needs, not just customer buyers. He discusses the value of data exhaust—digital traces left by users—as a potential tool to empower individual productivity and well-being, citing examples like Microsoft Outlook’s social uses and Facebook’s early success with user-focused insights. He contrasts automating technologies that control workers with informing technologies that respect expertise, as seen in power plant operators’ software. Throughout, Sam calls for user-centered design that addresses workplace realities of stress, mistrust, and techno-overload to create tools that workers actually want, adopt, and benefit from.
Key Insights
-
•
Enterprise software historically prioritized buyers over users, causing poor adoption and alienation.
-
•
Digitization in workplaces can reduce valuable social interactions, leading to worker isolation.
-
•
Workers actively resist technologies they dislike, a behavior rooted in longstanding workplace sociology.
-
•
Theory X management, which assumes workers shirk work, still dominates and shapes enterprise UX.
-
•
Despite early skepticism, tools like digital calendars became widely adopted by shifting user benefit perceptions.
-
•
Data exhaust refers to the digital footprints users leave, which can be harnessed to empower users with personal insights.
-
•
Personal data is more valuable to individual users than aggregated big data used by management.
-
•
Social uses of enterprise tools, such as humorous meeting invites in Microsoft Outlook, increase adoption and productivity.
-
•
Informating technology supports user expertise and decision-making, unlike automating technology that enforces control.
-
•
Many enterprises still lack effective mobile apps, contributing to disjointed, stressful user experiences.
Notable Quotes
"Building Windows is like ordering pizza for a billion people—everyone is your user."
"The insurance clerks were chained to their desks, no longer making quick social pop-overs to colleagues."
"The quick pop over to check on a file actually leads to a whole bunch of ancillary benefits, like social bonds."
"Nobody’s going to use digital calendars because they’re just more work and no benefit."
"Workplaces are in trouble: only 13% of workers worldwide are actively engaged at work."
"One in four American workers actively distrust their employers, believing they lie regularly."
"If you’re a Theory X manager, you believe work is something people hate and must be controlled."
"Enterprise user experiences are often customer experiences, not user experiences."
"Users left data trails—data exhaust—that can actually inform and empower them if designed well."
"Zuboff called it informating technology—technology that serves users by providing insight, not just automating tasks."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"If you said are you creative, I’m gonna say hell yeah."
Dr. Karl JeffriesThe Science of Creativity for DesignOps
January 8, 2024
"Show them, don’t tell them — involving stakeholders early builds skin in the game and helps control quality."
Amy MarquezINVEST: Discussion
June 15, 2018
"Trust is built by showing you’re there to help make them succeed, not just push your agenda."
Steve Portigal Chris Chapo Kelly Goto Christian RohrerDiscussion
May 13, 2015
"Dedicated staffing gives designers deep vertical mastery but limits horizontal experience."
Alicia MootyDesign Staffing Models
September 30, 2021
"Research in science fiction helps make research real and creative all the time."
Ana Maria Montero Barrantes Aditi Dhar Michelle Kaplan Nate Osborne Matt LaurenceThe Authentic UX Talent Show
January 8, 2024
"Operations tends to be something companies only think about when they are scaling rapidly, but investing early is essential."
Lada Gorlenko Sharbani Dhar Sébastien Malo Rob Mitzel Ivana Ng Michal Anne RogondinoTheme 1: Discussion
January 8, 2024
"Choosing a research repository is a big battle in your organization; the right decisions can really help you succeed."
Sofia QuinteroThe Product Philosophy Behind EnjoyHQ
March 10, 2021
"When things start to go bad, we’re going to pull the plug on it immediately—that helps build trust."
Laura KleinUnique challenges of innovation in enterprises
April 23, 2020
"Without Jim, what we're going to see today would have been a lot worse."
Andrew MichaelBuilding a Product Insights Team
March 10, 2022
