Risk and Reward: How to Diversify the Field of Civic Innovators and Designers
Justin Entzminger
Innovation Practice Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation at Johns Hopkins University
Terrance Smith
Bloomberg Public Innovation Fellow, Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg Center For Public Innovation
Tracy M. Colunga
Civic Engagement Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation at Johns Hopkins University
Mai-Ling Garcia
Digital Practice Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation
Summary
Key Insights
-
•
Designing in the public sector involves risk aversion, especially for professionals of color who face greater penalties for failure.
-
•
Credentialing and highlighting wins of marginalized designers helps legitimize their authority and fosters trust in civic innovation.
-
•
Tracy became the first Latina Chief Innovation Officer in Long Beach, supported by Mayor Garcia, who prioritized diverse hires to reflect community demographics.
-
•
Embedding designers who share the cultural backgrounds of community members improves resonance and trust in user-centered design efforts.
-
•
Hiring people with lived experience and non-traditional design resumes increases design effectiveness in municipal environments.
-
•
Tools like Post-it notes and digital boards democratize community input by preventing dominant voices from overshadowing others.
-
•
Reconfiguring physical meeting spaces and allowing community members to lead design sessions creates more inclusive innovation environments.
-
•
Traditional public sector job eligibility requirements limit access for diverse, emerging design talent; flexible hiring pathways help mitigate this.
-
•
Intentional recruitment efforts targeting local communities and historically Black colleges and universities build pipelines of diverse innovators.
-
•
Global efforts, such as in Guatemala City, show how user-centered design can be 'tropicalized' to local contexts by adapting language and culture.
Notable Quotes
"City Hall is often risk-averse, and professionals of color face extra penalties for taking risks in their careers."
"Designers must mitigate risk for their projects, but they personally face bigger risks from failure."
"As a young Black man with long hair entering traditional civic spaces, I had to prove my authority through support from leaders like the mayor."
"Mayor Garcia took a chance on me, and I then took chances on young designers who reflected Long Beach’s diverse community."
"Hiring designers who look like the community you serve makes a huge difference in user-centered design outcomes."
"Embedding community members to lead design sessions helps shift power dynamics and surfaces authentic voices."
"Post-its give everyone an equal playing field, preventing dominant voices from overshadowing others in community conversations."
"Traditional job requirements like college degrees and supervisory experience can bar otherwise skilled candidates in the public sector."
"We recruited locally and from historically Black colleges and universities to build a diverse and talented innovation team."
"In Guatemala City, we tropicalize design methods—doing things à la tortres—to fit our unique languages and cultures."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"If you value innovation and design, then you're investing in creativity."
Dr. Karl JeffriesThe Science of Creativity for DesignOps
January 8, 2024
"Creating internal champions in client organizations helps improve adoption and reduces churn."
Amy MarquezINVEST: Discussion
June 15, 2018
"The core of it is really putting yourself in that other person’s shoes—it’s basic but essential empathy."
Steve Portigal Chris Chapo Kelly Goto Christian RohrerDiscussion
May 13, 2015
"Agency style staffing allows designers to bring learnings across multiple projects and grow through new challenges."
Alicia MootyDesign Staffing Models
September 30, 2021
"For the right audience, if applied correctly, humor and music can move people in many ways."
Ana Maria Montero Barrantes Aditi Dhar Michelle Kaplan Nate Osborne Matt LaurenceThe Authentic UX Talent Show
January 8, 2024
"We never compromise on the business goals, but how we achieve them can be flexible and pragmatic."
Lada Gorlenko Sharbani Dhar Sébastien Malo Rob Mitzel Ivana Ng Michal Anne RogondinoTheme 1: Discussion
January 8, 2024
"Research isn’t linear; it’s messy and modular, so your tools have to reflect that fluidity."
Sofia QuinteroThe Product Philosophy Behind EnjoyHQ
March 10, 2021
"If you think innovation can happen without buy-in from the CEO, I would love to see that; I have not seen it work."
Laura KleinUnique challenges of innovation in enterprises
April 23, 2020
"Marketing is an essential collaborator because they help package and communicate insights organization-wide."
Andrew MichaelBuilding a Product Insights Team
March 10, 2022