Summary
This talk aims to unpack the notion of participation used in participatory design research, by proposing a framework through which different levels of participation can occur at different stages of the research process. Drawing examples of work in child welfare and foster care, this framework is ultimately an invitation to challenge the notion that participation is binary (i.e., either research is participatory or isn't) or fixed (i.e., there is only one way participation can be done). Instead, participation is a negotiation that should take into account different factors (e.g., partners, resources, timeline), and could include a combination of different levels at different stages in any given research study.
Key Insights
-
•
Participation in research can reduce ingest control experienced by marginalized communities.
-
•
Sherry Arnstein's ladder of citizen participation provides a foundational framework for understanding participation levels.
-
•
An effective model of participation is not binary but exists on a continuum based on the research process stages.
-
•
The spiral model in participatory action research emphasizes ongoing feedback and participant engagement throughout the research lifecycle.
-
•
Co-creating research questions and instruments with affected communities can lead to more meaningful research.
-
•
Transparency in participant selection and recruitment can build trust and agency among community members.
-
•
Participatory research should include mechanisms for participant validation of findings to ensure their voices are accurately represented.
-
•
Ethics in participatory research involve not only engaging participants but also ensuring their well-being and compensation for contributions.
-
•
Research methodologies should adapt to the developmental stages of participants, particularly when working with youth.
-
•
Participatory models should avoid superficial metrics and instead focus on quality and depth of engagement.
Notable Quotes
"Participation is one way to minimize ingest control."
"Instead of asking is this research participatory, we should ask when and how participatory is this research."
"The more participation, the better is a simplified view of what participation can mean."
"Participation is an ethical commitment."
"Being participatory does not mean that you’re being trauma responsive."
"It’s important to reflect on how participation can lend itself to different stages of the research process."
"The typology is less about theorizing the perfect model of participation and more about mapping existing forms."
"Participatory research is not inherently void of harm or power differentials."
"An external organization having the last word on the study findings represents a critical power dynamic."
"We can and should complement participation with an ethic of care."
















More Videos
"If you go to where you're loved, you'll find more support for your design ideas."
Discussion
June 9, 2017

"Optimization through Slack can help us be gentler to each other."
Bria AlexanderTheme 1 Intro
September 23, 2024

"We have the top quality rate in the space for participants."
Benjamin Wiedmaier Annie MayfieldRedefining Toolkits: Unbundling to Create a Perfect Match
March 11, 2025

"It's not just about the design; design and product need to collaborate effectively."
Eniola OluwoleLessons From the DesignOps Journey of the World's Largest Travel Site
October 24, 2019

"User-centered design resonates when our designers look like the community."
Justin Entzminger Terrance Smith Tracy M. Colunga Mai-Ling GarciaRisk and Reward: How to Diversify the Field of Civic Innovators and Designers
November 17, 2022

"Welcome to day three of Design Ops Summit 2023."
Bria AlexanderOpening Remarks
October 4, 2023

"Can you sit down with the people that you work with?"
Holly ColeUnderstanding Experiences: When you have to do more than work
November 8, 2018

"Context is not a container; it's a dynamic construct that shapes human experiences."
Mohammad Hossein JarrahiContextuality problem: Exploring the Benefits of Qualitative and Quantitative Research
January 20, 2023

"A lot of times organizations have the benefit of having data from user experience research from analytics."
Brad Peters Anne MamaghaniShort Take #1: UX/Product Lessons from Your Industry Peers
December 6, 2022