Risk and Reward: How to Diversify the Field of Civic Innovators and Designers
Justin Entzminger
Innovation Practice Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation at Johns Hopkins University
Terrance Smith
Bloomberg Public Innovation Fellow, Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg Center For Public Innovation
Tracy M. Colunga
Civic Engagement Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation at Johns Hopkins University
Mai-Ling Garcia
Digital Practice Director, Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation
Summary
The role of innovator and civic designer is often one that pushes for change, sees things through a different lens. However, people with marginalized identities are often challenged to be seen, heard, and make an impact in work places. We will chat about our challenges as innovators in homogeneous spaces, but also tactics and tools we can use to help diverse groups of people be champions of change in civic spaces. This session will unpack the ways in which our hidden biases can minimize the contributions of designers and how we can uplift groups of people as champions of change.
Key Insights
-
•
Designing in the public sector involves risk aversion, especially for professionals of color who face greater penalties for failure.
-
•
Credentialing and highlighting wins of marginalized designers helps legitimize their authority and fosters trust in civic innovation.
-
•
Tracy became the first Latina Chief Innovation Officer in Long Beach, supported by Mayor Garcia, who prioritized diverse hires to reflect community demographics.
-
•
Embedding designers who share the cultural backgrounds of community members improves resonance and trust in user-centered design efforts.
-
•
Hiring people with lived experience and non-traditional design resumes increases design effectiveness in municipal environments.
-
•
Tools like Post-it notes and digital boards democratize community input by preventing dominant voices from overshadowing others.
-
•
Reconfiguring physical meeting spaces and allowing community members to lead design sessions creates more inclusive innovation environments.
-
•
Traditional public sector job eligibility requirements limit access for diverse, emerging design talent; flexible hiring pathways help mitigate this.
-
•
Intentional recruitment efforts targeting local communities and historically Black colleges and universities build pipelines of diverse innovators.
-
•
Global efforts, such as in Guatemala City, show how user-centered design can be 'tropicalized' to local contexts by adapting language and culture.
Notable Quotes
"City Hall is often risk-averse, and professionals of color face extra penalties for taking risks in their careers."
"Designers must mitigate risk for their projects, but they personally face bigger risks from failure."
"As a young Black man with long hair entering traditional civic spaces, I had to prove my authority through support from leaders like the mayor."
"Mayor Garcia took a chance on me, and I then took chances on young designers who reflected Long Beach’s diverse community."
"Hiring designers who look like the community you serve makes a huge difference in user-centered design outcomes."
"Embedding community members to lead design sessions helps shift power dynamics and surfaces authentic voices."
"Post-its give everyone an equal playing field, preventing dominant voices from overshadowing others in community conversations."
"Traditional job requirements like college degrees and supervisory experience can bar otherwise skilled candidates in the public sector."
"We recruited locally and from historically Black colleges and universities to build a diverse and talented innovation team."
"In Guatemala City, we tropicalize design methods—doing things à la tortres—to fit our unique languages and cultures."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Designers are becoming increasingly interested in doing their own tactical user research within sprint cycles."
Caroline VizeThe State of UX: Five Lessons from 2021 to Accelerate Digital Experience in 2022
March 9, 2022
"We created recruitment events for underrepresented groups because it was harder for them to get permission and sign up in time otherwise."
Kara KaneCommunities of Practice for Civic Design
April 7, 2022
"Design teams face challenges because inputs live in PDFs, Figma files, Slack messages, spreadsheets, and more."
Jon Fukuda Ellie KryslDesign Planning and Management Support
October 3, 2023
"Don’t dress for the job you have, dress for the job you want—this applies to people and companies alike."
Mark TempletonCreating a Legacy: the ultimate experience
June 9, 2017
"That’s not who you are. You’re better than that."
Jim KalbachPeace is waged with sticky notes: Mapping Real-World Experiences
June 14, 2018
"Community-built packs and templates allow users to make money by sharing their automations and workflows."
Scott StephensThe Next Generation in DesignOps Toolsets
July 28, 2022
"Low status looks like slumping, shuffling feet, and avoiding eye contact but seeking approval."
Cheryl PlatzCollaborative Creativity through Improv
November 7, 2018
"Best practice is past practice and context changes, so it’s no longer guaranteed to be effective."
Jen BriselliLearning Is The Engine: Designing & Adapting in a World We Can’t Predict
April 16, 2025
"User research excels at explaining why things happen; data science explains what and how; together they build trusted insight."
Mac SmithMeasuring Up: Using Product Research for Organizational Impact
March 12, 2021
Latest Books All books
Dig deeper with the Rosenbot
What new workflows or tools have been effective in bridging the gap between design, engineering, and product teams using AI?
How should designers decide if AI is appropriate for high-stakes systems like community health?
How can designers regain control over AI-generated designs to maintain quality?