It Takes GRIT: Lessons from the Small, but Mighty World of Civic Usability Testing
Summary
While usability testing is an often overlooked part of design in the frenzied race to get technology to market, it’s absence is especially problematic when it comes to civic-focused products and services. Even when designers want to test, options are often limited to "professional testers" or personal networks - far from the actual users they’re hoping to help. Testing with a diverse group of end users and stakeholders is the only surefire way to make sure what gets designed works for everyone, but the approach needs to be thoughtful, sensitive and impactful. Since launching in early 2019, GRIT has delivered more than 20 such inclusive usability testing engagements with partners in the public, private and nonprofit sectors and we’re eager to share our insights with others who endeavor to engage diverse, underrepresented communities in the design of their civic products and services. Using case studies and lessons from our trove of civic design engagements, we'll help take the guesswork out of inclusively testing your next design.
Key Insights
-
•
Inclusive usability testing uncovers user needs that would otherwise be missed, especially for vulnerable populations.
-
•
Building a diverse participant pool requires going offline to meet people in their everyday community spaces, not just digital recruitment.
-
•
Offering flexible testing times beyond standard working hours increases participation from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds.
-
•
Creating a comfortable, informal testing environment with snacks and a non-intimidating setting improves honest feedback.
-
•
Clear, jargon-free communication and early sharing of consent forms build trust and reduce participant anxiety.
-
•
Maintaining a single point of contact for participants prevents confusion and fosters smoother coordination.
-
•
Compensation at a rate of $1 to $1.25 per minute, reimbursed travel, and prompt payments boost recruitment speed and retention.
-
•
Referrals from satisfied testers can help reach specific demographics and expand testing pools efficiently.
-
•
Longitudinal testing, involving participants multiple times, enhances insights as the product evolves.
-
•
Testing with real users who rely on assistive technologies, like screen readers or voice commands, validates accessibility effectively.
Notable Quotes
"If it doesn’t work for you, it doesn’t work."
"When you test inclusively, you’re learning about the people who will be directly impacted by your work, your users."
"Technology that includes everyone, especially those from vulnerable populations, ensures that what gets built will work for everyone."
"Participant experience is everything and it starts with building trust."
"No surprises. Tell participants everything they’ll be experiencing from who will be in the room to if the session will be recorded."
"Use plain language in all communication. No design or technology jargon."
"Build your pool, build your practice. If you provide a great testing experience, you’ve got another person to add to your group."
"Compensation is so important to thank people for their time, and you will definitely build your recruitment pool much faster if you offer it."
"We intentionally did not email listservs or go on Twitter because that would have delivered a group that is too tech-savvy."
"During testing sensitive subjects, have relevant resources at the ready, like shelter beds for participants in need."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Managing up assumes research is below something, but I see advising as partnerships and equals."
Christian MadsbjergInfluencing Strategy
March 31, 2020
"We cannot practice women-centricity without including an active role for men."
Mansi GuptaWomen-Centric Research: What, Why, How
March 29, 2023
"When things get more complicated than expected, we re-negotiate scope or assign a full designer to keep quality."
Nora Tejeda Giovanna AlonsoScaling Design Capabilities at BBVA Through a Self-service Design Model
June 10, 2021
"Just because you do more sessions or add review moments doesn’t mean the quality of engagement improves."
Sarah FathallahA Typology of Participation in Participatory Research
March 28, 2023
"At the VA we explored how veterans understood or didn’t understand the services they were eligible for and uncovered many blockers."
Alison Rand Sarah BrooksScaling Impact with Service Design
March 25, 2021
"Mobile is the first major platform where accessibility features are built in and mature."
Sam ProulxMobile Accessibility: Why Moving Accessibility Beyond the Desktop is Critical in a Mobile-first World
September 8, 2022
"The most successful way to ask about job function is a single-select question, not an open field."
Sydney LawsonAnatomy of a Strong User Panel
March 10, 2026
"The goal is to turn research into a partner in shared discovery, not just an arbiter of truth."
Kristen Guth, Ph.D.Out of the FOG: A Non-traditional Research Approach to Alignment
March 28, 2023
"Asking for help and humbling yourself is one of the most powerful ways to grow as a researcher."
Sam Ladner Megan Blocker Tanvi Dhond Katie Hansen Ricardo MartinsMethodologies: Beyond the interview [Advancing Research Community Workshop Series]
September 4, 2024
