SUS: A System Unusable for Twenty Percent of the Population
Summary
Did you know that the SUS creates biases in your research, affecting one in five people? That’s right! People with disabilities, especially those who use assistive technology, are not considered by most of the questions in the SUS. When the SUS was invented, the author encouraged people to change it to suit different needs. In this talk, Samuel Proulx and Abid Virani from Fable will discuss how Fable adapted the SUS to work for assistive technology users. Drawing from over five thousand hours of research and testing involving assistive technology users, we created the Accessible Usability Scale (AUS). This presentation will include trends in AUS responses since it was released in December of 2020.
Key Insights
-
•
Assistive technologies mainly split into screen readers, screen magnifiers, and alternative navigation devices, each with distinct user needs.
-
•
Screen reader users heavily rely on semantic web structure and proper labeling for efficient navigation.
-
•
Magnification users often supplement their experience with screen reader features to reduce eye strain.
-
•
Alternative navigation users use multiple input methods like voice commands and head mice, providing fallback options.
-
•
Traditional usability labs and standard SUS questionnaires fail to consider unique accessibility challenges and setup of assistive tech users.
-
•
SUS questions like needing technical support or learning speed are confusing or irrelevant to assistive tech users without adaptation.
-
•
Fable created the Accessible Usability Scale to better evaluate assistive tech user experience by adapting question language and scope.
-
•
Preliminary AUS data indicates screen reader users experience the lowest usability scores due to lack of backup input methods.
-
•
Remote usability testing greatly increases participation and authentic results by allowing users to test in familiar, customized environments.
-
•
User skill with assistive tech, experience level, and mental models vary significantly and must be considered beyond linear novice-expert scales.
Notable Quotes
"Assistive technology includes software and hardware that people with disabilities use to access computers."
"Screen readers let us jump directly to content, replicating visual skimming of a web page."
"Expert screen reader users listen at over 300 words per minute and still fully understand the content."
"Magnification can cover the entire screen two to ten times, and users pan around to see different areas."
"Many magnification tools also have screen reader functions to reduce eye strain and help users."
"Alternative navigation users might use voice commands, head mice, or grid coordinates to access elements."
"Traditional usability labs often force assistive tech users to use unfamiliar setups, creating barriers."
"I am a technical person, yet I might still need someone who can see to help me use certain sites."
"Accessibility is a spectrum; if frequent tasks require assistance, the product is inaccessible for me."
"Remote testing helps get closer to real-world results because users are in environments customized for them."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"I wasted five years being blind to the rhythm of the place before we moved billions of dollars addressing major issues."
Christian MadsbjergInfluencing Strategy
March 31, 2020
"Solutions range on a spectrum from offensive and impartial to informed and holistic toward women."
Mansi GuptaWomen-Centric Research: What, Why, How
March 29, 2023
"The design at scale model changes mindsets: designers become guides, and developers begin to see the value and want to learn design."
Nora Tejeda Giovanna AlonsoScaling Design Capabilities at BBVA Through a Self-service Design Model
June 10, 2021
"We formed a lived expert review board to support framing conclusions and decisions, rebalancing power from academic peer reviewers."
Sarah FathallahA Typology of Participation in Participatory Research
March 28, 2023
"People often go along with the outcome if they feel they were part of the process."
Alison Rand Sarah BrooksScaling Impact with Service Design
March 25, 2021
"Accessible mobile designs can be reused on desktop, but desktop-first accessibility is harder to transfer to mobile."
Sam ProulxMobile Accessibility: Why Moving Accessibility Beyond the Desktop is Critical in a Mobile-first World
September 8, 2022
"Every single one of these companies has a landing page on their marketing website with a call to action to sign up."
Sydney LawsonAnatomy of a Strong User Panel
March 10, 2026
"If a stakeholder claims something is a fact without evidence, it is our responsibility as researchers to challenge and unpack that."
Kristen Guth, Ph.D.Out of the FOG: A Non-traditional Research Approach to Alignment
March 28, 2023
"People generally want to help and tell what they genuinely believe; they’re just terrible at accurate recall."
Sam Ladner Megan Blocker Tanvi Dhond Katie Hansen Ricardo MartinsMethodologies: Beyond the interview [Advancing Research Community Workshop Series]
September 4, 2024