Rosenverse

Log in or create a free Rosenverse account to watch this video.

Log in Create free account

100s of community videos are available to free members. Conference talks are generally available to Gold members.

AI for Information Architects: Are the robots coming for our jobs?
Thursday, November 21, 2024 • Rosenfeld Community
Share the love for this talk
AI for Information Architects: Are the robots coming for our jobs?
Speakers: Karen McGrane and Jeff Eaton
Link:

Summary

Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools like large language models present opportunities — and risks — for people working with digital content. Can AI help with tedious tasks, like encoding and categorizing documents, or rewriting text snippets? Will AI be so good at these tasks that Information Architects (IAs) are no longer needed? In this session, Jeff and Karen provide an overview of what "AI" means for IAs, explaining the differences between natural language processing, machine learning, and large language models. They also dig into a real-world example of using different systems to categorize web content from Reddit. IAs will come away from the session reassured that the robots pose no threat to their jobs.

Key Insights

  • AI’s vast hype often overshadows its practical limitations in nuanced tasks like taxonomy creation and content categorization.

  • Natural language processing excels at tokenizing and quantifying text but struggles with capturing deep contextual meaning and nuance.

  • Machine learning models rely heavily on quality training data and do not possess reasoning abilities; they identify patterns without true understanding.

  • Text embeddings convert documents into numerical vectors enabling proximity-based semantic search and clustering, offering fast but approximate classification.

  • Different AI models interpret the same content differently; model choice significantly affects results.

  • Large language models (LLMs) like chat GPT are very flexible but require explicit, narrowly defined prompts and guardrails to avoid off-task or fabricated outputs.

  • Accurate AI categorization of complex content is far from perfect; the best models achieved only about 47% accuracy in the Reddit post experiment.

  • Using AI at scale entails significant computational cost, time, and environmental impact that must be factored into decisions.

  • Information architects remain essential to breaking down complex tasks into clear, testable questions for AI and validating results.

  • Successful enterprise AI implementations, like Microsoft Learn, rely heavily on existing IA and content structure infrastructures rather than AI alone.

Notable Quotes

"What is AI gonna do for us? Are we afraid the robots will take our jobs? AI is a tool, not a replacement."

"You have to ask specific, very precise questions, not big general ones, to get useful AI results."

"Trying to map all possible connotations and context in language is mind-bogglingly computationally expensive."

"Natural language processing is basically about figuring out how to math words."

"Different AI models have wildly different views of the same content; the model choice makes a big difference."

"The biggest challenge with LLMs was keeping them on task instead of writing their own Reddit posts."

"The top LLM we tested got only 47% accuracy categorizing Reddit posts, which is sobering."

"Running AI categorization on 2000 posts took 38 hours, $19, and as much carbon as driving a 1998 Chevy Malibu from Philly to Brooklyn."

"The real value of AI in IA is as a collaborative tool requiring significant human support, not a magic knob to turn."

"AI-powered enterprise tools sit on top of the classic IA infrastructure; without it, AI can’t scale effectively."

Ask the Rosenbot
Andrew Michael
Building a Product Insights Team
2022 • Advancing Research 2022
Gold
Verónica Urzúa
The B-side of the Research Impact
2021 • Advancing Research 2021
Gold
Luke Wroblewski
Designing AI Applications
2026 • Rosenfeld Community
Peter Merholz
The Trials and Tribulations of Directors of UX
2023 • Enterprise Community
Tricia Wang
Spatial Collapse: Designing for Emergent Culture
2024 • Enterprise Experience 2020
Gold
Elizabeth Churchill
Exploring Cadence: You, Your Team, and Your Enterprise
2017 • Enterprise Experience 2017
Gold
Megan Blocker
Theme 2 Intro
2025 • Advancing Research 2025
Gold
Sam Proulx
SUS: A System Unusable for Twenty Percent of the Population
2021 • Civic Design 2021
Gold
Ned Gartside
Navigating accessibility and climate
2024 • Climate UX Interest Group
Benjamin Real
Showing the Value of DesignOps by Not Having a DesignOps Team
2020 • DesignOps Summit 2020
Gold
Joshua Noble
Casual Inference
2023 • QuantQual Interest Group
Laureen Kattan
Centering Patients and Clinicians in a Complex Government Ecosystem
2023 • Design in Product 2023
Gold
Victor M. Gonzalez
Practicing Learners and Learning Practitioners
2021 • Advancing Research 2021
Gold
Etienne Fang
The Power of Care: From Human-Centered Research to Humanity-Centered Leadership
2021 • Advancing Research 2021
Gold
Victor Lombardi
Bridging Design and Climate Science
2024 • Climate UX Interest Group
Bria Alexander
Opening Remarks
2022 • Civic Design 2022
Gold

More Videos

Louis Rosenfeld

"If your talk isn’t accepted, it doesn’t mean it’s bad—it might just not fit the program’s narrative arc or available slots."

Louis Rosenfeld Jemma Ahmed Christian Crumlish Uday Gajendar Chris Geison

Coffee with Lou #3: What Makes for a Successful UX Conference Presentation?

May 2, 2024

Jilanna Wilson

"We couldn’t find just one word to describe our third value so we made one up: humbladent—humble and confident together."

Jilanna Wilson

Distributed Design Operations Management

October 23, 2019

Matt Webb

"What makes it different is that it doesn’t run sequentially; you give it a goal and it decides how to achieve it."

Matt Webb

Context Window: Five Futures for AI

June 11, 2025

Sam Proulx

"Everyone already uses accessibility features whether you have a disability or not."

Sam Proulx

Accessibility: An Opportunity to Innovate

September 8, 2022

Theresa Neil

"You aren't going to understand the healthcare ecosystem right off the bat; it’s incredibly complex."

Theresa Neil

Designing for Wellness: Specializing in Healthcare

May 22, 2024

Peter Van Dijck

"The more I work with evals, the more I think UX and product people need to be involved because of the need for diverse perspectives."

Peter Van Dijck

Hands-on AI #2: Understanding evals: LLM as a Judge

October 15, 2025

Rachel Posman

"How are executives going to invest in you if you don’t show the work? If they can’t see it, they won’t invest."

Rachel Posman John Calhoun

"Ask Me Anything" with Rachel Posman and John Calhoun, Authors of the Upcoming Rosenfeld Book, The Design Conductors

September 25, 2024

Tricia Wang

"Building trust across functions means simple acts like scheduling lunch or coffee meetings with no agenda."

Tricia Wang

The most popular design thinking strategy is BS

January 27, 2022

Sarah Auslander

"Always design a thing by considering it in this next largest temporal context — a day in a month, a decade in a century."

Sarah Auslander Betsy Ramaccia Gordon Ross

Insights Panel

November 18, 2022