Cleaning Up Our Mess: Digital Governance for Designers
Summary
The Internet and Web have reached a tipping point. We’re now witnessing the surfacing of harmful patterns and norms that we designed—often unintentionally—into our products, services, and communities, and the world we live in. Designers who work in the enterprise are, like their peers in startups and big dotcoms, vulnerable and culpable and need to consider some big questions: How well do we manage our data? How inclusive are our development practices? How broadly and deeply do we think about the impact of what we build and deploy before we scale it for our customer base? We need to move forward with intent. We need to govern our digital spaces. A necessary first step towards that goal involves designers examining—with honesty and introspection—our role in the creation of what’s online. The World Wide Web is nothing more than the accumulation of what digital makers have put there. We made this mess, and we need to talk about how we are going to clean it up. Digital governance expert Lisa Welchman will reflect on how 25 years of passionate and agile web development got us where we are today, and the consequences of the lack of self-governance by the digital maker community. She will show us a path forward from this mess, outlining questions we can ask and steps we can take to govern better what we have created and what we will create in the future.
Key Insights
-
•
Digital governance is fundamentally about decision making and organizational responsibility, not just tools or workflows.
-
•
Many digital governance failures stem from unclear ownership of strategy, policy, and standards within organizations.
-
•
Collaborative governance involves multiple levels: core strategy teams, distributed content makers, working groups, and community contributors.
-
•
External vendors often deepen digital silos if not properly integrated into governance frameworks.
-
•
Governance can be designed to enable speed and innovation, not just control or restriction.
-
•
The internet and digital technologies undergo a lengthy maturation cycle similar to historic technologies like automobiles.
-
•
Algorithmic biases often reflect organizational biases; fixing algorithms requires fixing institutions.
-
•
Proactive digital safety can be conceptualized like crash-test dummies for online systems, focusing on inclusivity, morality, and safety.
-
•
Participation in internet and web governance organizations like W3C or the Internet Society is crucial but underutilized by digital professionals.
-
•
Generosity and sharing cultures, as exemplified by the development of the three-point seatbelt, are critical for progressing digital governance.
Notable Quotes
"People can have the same values and ideas but if you don’t tune them properly, you just don’t get what you want."
"Digital governance is about who’s supposed to make the decision, not what the decision is."
"Governance isn’t the byproduct of a project; digital is a system you have to design and iterate continuously."
"You can’t expect people to comply with standards if you don’t know who they are."
"Your external vendors may not have your organizational best interests at heart because it’s not their business model."
"Governance frameworks can facilitate whatever pace or style of work an organization wants."
"Every bad thing that can happen in the real world can now happen on the internet — and every good thing too."
"Human biases are the real problem behind algorithmic bias because organizations embed those biases first."
"We are the fix — everything online is made by people, so we can change it together."
"Governance participation isn’t optional if you want to avoid reactive impositions down the line."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"There has to be some connection between our results and how our partners see the value in it."
Jemma Ahmed Chris GeisonBridge Building across Research Disciplines
August 26, 2021
"Evaluation might be the most important part of your entire development effort and is often the hardest to do well."
Sarah BarrettAI in Real Life: Using LLMs to Turbocharge Microsoft Learn
February 13, 2025
"The squint test helps you see if the right elements are popping on the page without distraction."
Billy CarlsonPro-level UI Tips for Beginners
September 9, 2022
"Transparency can be a master source of efficiency when people are trusted to share."
Niko LaitinenAdaptable Org Design for Resilient Times
June 10, 2021
"We developed this research framework during our time at Uber together with an extended leadership team as the team grew from 30 to 100."
George Zhang Molly StevensUX Research Excellence Framework
March 11, 2021
"The QX score combines behavioral and attitudinal metrics to better understand what users do and why."
Dana Bishop2022: The Year UX Demonstrates its Business Impact
March 11, 2022
"What role does time play as a form of currency in contributing to extractive methods of research?"
Sahibzada MayedThe Politics of Radical Research: A Manifesto
March 27, 2023
"Managers with more burnout score 34 points lower on feeling safe to speak up than those with none."
Alla WeinbergPeople Are Sick of Change: Psychological Safety is the Cure
July 20, 2023
"If you wait for permission, you will probably never be granted it. Just start doing what you know to be the right thing."
Lori Muszynski Peter MerholzKeeping Design Weird
October 2, 2023
