Hands or Brains? How to Hire for Strategy, Strategically
Summary
Hiring a consultant is no different from hiring talent: you need to look both for hard and soft skills if you want a successful and fruitful relationship. The most commonly used selection criteria, visual impact of the portfolio, same-industry experience, results achieved and price competitiveness don’t necessarily help to make a better selection. This presentation contains samples of the three key skills to look for, how they were critical in project success, and how to look for these skills in a consultancy.
Key Insights
-
•
Hiring for known problems calls for 'hands,' while unknown problems require 'brains' with strategic skills.
-
•
Evaluating agencies by portfolio visuals emphasizes output, not problem-solving effectiveness.
-
•
Industry-specific experience is less important than demonstrated expertise across diverse challenges.
-
•
Higher price does not guarantee better strategic capabilities; agencies also optimize their margins.
-
•
Partnership mindset leads to value creation by challenging client assumptions rather than just delivering services.
-
•
Successful strategy projects must produce solutions adopted company-wide, not just isolated deliverables.
-
•
Facilitating cross-department collaboration, especially with technical teams, is key to project success.
-
•
Flexibility means aligning on goals despite differing methodologies or tools, not simply adapting processes.
-
•
Listening to how agencies navigate organizational context reveals leadership beyond technical execution.
-
•
Proposals often better reveal strategic thinking and innovation than interviews alone.
Notable Quotes
"If you care about the solution, you’re much better off hiring hands."
"A vendor provides a service, but a partner delivers value."
"Knowing the difference between hands and brains is key to managing expectations."
"Choosing an agency based on portfolio visuals is focusing on output, not on how effective the solution was."
"The biggest challenge of a project is building a solution that’s going to be adopted company-wide."
"Flexibility is not about using the same methodologies; it’s about moving together towards the same goal."
"Big picture thinkers move past obstacles and create unexpected paths and new solutions."
"You find the right fit when someone challenges your assumptions and provides a different perspective."
"Success is about not sacrificing quality, not about mere integration."
"Listening for leadership is about understanding how they navigate a project beyond the solution."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"The only thing that makes a title change is how you behave and deliver in the room."
Adam Cutler Karen Pascoe Ian Swinson Susan WorthmanDiscussion
June 8, 2016
"Dashboards in the DP&M system let design leads visualize all screens, components, templates, and content types in context, identifying inconsistencies or opportunities."
Ellie Krysl Jon FukudaPlanned Right. Managed Right. Designed Right.
June 6, 2023
"Engineers didn’t understand why they were building what they were building, and product managers didn’t understand what engineers were building."
Anat Fintzi Rachel MinnicksDelivering at Scale: Making Traction with Resistant Partners
June 9, 2022
"Carol was really grateful for our conversation."
Randolph Duke IIWar Stories LIVE! Randy Duke II
March 30, 2020
"Life has a way of working itself out."
Maria GiudiceEmpowering change: Reigniting purpose, passion and impact in research
March 13, 2025
"Trust was cultivated with design principles like clarity, efficiency, consistency, and beauty serving as a North Star."
Nalini P. KotamrajuAn Organizational Story: Salesforce Lightning Design System
June 9, 2016
"Reflecting on our power as implementers of policy, we must reciprocate by giving back information and value to those we engage."
Aaron Stienstra Lashanda HodgeLeveraging Civic Design to Advance Equity and Rebuild Trust in the US Federal Government
December 8, 2021
"The goal of war gaming is to provide better quality information at the right time for better decisions."
Terry BuckmanWargaming (An Introduction)
August 10, 2023
"Power is a weird word. It's hard to relate to, and we aren't usually put in that position in our work."
Jess GrecoClaiming your power: Practical tools for amplifying your unique voice
March 13, 2025
