Leading through ambiguity: Supporting a design team relearning their craft
This video is featured in the AI Conference playlist.
Summary
What started as workflow optimization became real-time field research into how designers learn, resist, and adapt when the act of creation itself changes. Familiar practices began to break, observing where problem framing eroded, critique expanded instead of converging, and experience stopped guaranteeing great judgment.
This talk is an ongoing case study in leading teams through that shift. It also reflects on how our internal experience designing with AI became a critical lens for understanding the people we build for.
Key Insights
-
•
AI-generated content often hides a reasoning gap where the AI's assumptions diverge from the creator's original intentions.
-
•
Polished AI outputs create a false sense of completion, making it harder to question or critique the work effectively.
-
•
Humans are poor judges of how much AI is actually helping; confidence from AI can be misleading.
-
•
Visible reasoning features in AI tools often do not accurately reflect the model's true decision-making process.
-
•
Design critique collapses when teams fail to name clear criteria for judgment and when responsibility for AI outputs is unclear.
-
•
Adaptation to AI is less about acquiring new tools and more about clearing away noise and reclaiming existing core skills.
-
•
The role identity of designers is shifting from deeply hidden craft to more visible communication and reasoning skills akin to management.
-
•
Leadership must recognize when team members struggle to adapt and balance support with holding expectations to maintain impact.
-
•
Rapid AI tool adoption increases the volume of outputs faster than teams can inspect or align on underlying reasoning.
-
•
Building bridges across the reasoning gap requires shared language and explicit articulation of decisions during AI-assisted workflows.
Notable Quotes
"The gap between what the output says and what the intention was is what we're going to call the reasoning gap."
"AI doesn't make bad ideas more dangerous. It makes unfinished ideas more convincing."
"The number of crossings between intention and generation is increasing faster than our ability to examine what happened between them."
"Between your prompt and prototype, the AI made 40 decisions that you can't trace."
"The shown reasoning wasn't the actual reasoning. It was just a pretty story to get us to trust it."
"If you're presenting a concept, you're endorsing it. You need to be able to say why."
"What AI is asking out of every individual contributor is to take on the skill set of a manager."
"When tired becomes the norm, people get playful again because they stop being married to the tools and start being curious about what's next."
"Your job as a leader isn't just empathy. It's naming what the new system requires and holding the line."
"The work right now isn't about outrunning the reasoning gap. The goal is to build bridges across it."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"You don’t get anyone to do anything."
Matt LeMayYou Don’t “Get” Anyone to Do Anything
December 6, 2022
"Our design language gives broad ditches on either side of the road with some nuance, but no rigid libraries at first."
Phil GilbertA Consistent Culture of Design
May 14, 2015
"Affordable, powerful AI and data-driven design have become shockingly practical for enterprise settings."
Louis RosenfeldWelcome / Housekeeping
June 6, 2023
"The pressure to produce insights quickly defines many organizations shaped by 'move fast and break things' culture."
Rachael Dietkus, LCSWThe power to heal and harm
March 13, 2025
"Tying insights directly into team backlogs or goals can transform research from information to active stakeholder in decisions."
Jake BurghardtFinding More Inroads into Research Impact
February 20, 2026
"Corporate leaders don’t know how to integrate design leaders beyond the design org."
Fatimah RichmondThe Future of ReOps as a Strategic Function: A Roadmap for Getting There
March 25, 2024
"Psychological safety is key—if folks aren't in the right state, the conversation isn't productive."
Joshua GravesWe Need To Talk: Managing Ludicrous Requests at Work (Part 3 of 3)
May 12, 2025
"If a security camera were recording, what would they see? Focus on facts, not stories."
Joshua GravesWe Need To Talk: Navigating Conversations with Your Boss (Part 1 of 3)
April 14, 2025
"I’ve become a subversive designer because I’m now considered a product leader using prioritization at the organizational level."
Harry MaxPriority Zero: Some Things are More Equal than Others
June 9, 2016
