Summary
In this case study, we’ll share how one large design org began reshaping its feedback culture by focusing not just on what gets reviewed, but how we talk about work. The turning point wasn’t a new tool—it was unlearning long-held assumptions: that critique is a milestone, that it’s only for finished work, or that feedback is something senior people give and juniors receive. We’ll walk through how we introduced lightweight feedback rituals, role-based archetypes, and a simple starter kit to help designers ask for the feedback they actually need—earlier, more confidently, and with more clarity. Along the way, we’ll share the bumps, lessons, and shifts in mindset it took to make critique feel like a creative tool, not a performance review. You’ll leave with practical ideas to build a culture of feedback—and a deeper appreciation for the messy, human side of improving our craft together.
Key Insights
-
•
Feedback is a system that requires choreography, timing, and targeting to truly move design work forward.
-
•
Poorly framed feedback with conflicting comments and no clear ask causes confusion and stalls progress.
-
•
Amazon Devices built a feedback engine with defined rituals at different maturity stages to scale quality feedback for 500 designers.
-
•
Strong feedback is anchored in a clear intent, specific observations, actionable guidance, and ends with a next step and owner.
-
•
Feedback is subjective by nature and should sharpen, not flatten, the intent behind creative work.
-
•
Negative feedback archetypes — like the monopolizer or the fog — erode trust and add churn in design processes.
-
•
Positive archetypes such as the clarifier, connector, and synthesizer help set examples for effective feedback contribution.
-
•
Feedback loops must be agile and adaptive; rigid linear processes do not fit fast-changing projects.
-
•
Late or contradictory feedback can often be mitigated by frequent, early crits and cross-team alignment.
-
•
Psychological safety and balancing candor with care are essential to making feedback a growth-focused investment.
Notable Quotes
"The hidden hero or villain of craft is really feedback, the quality of feedback that we give."
"Feedback is a system. It's not just a pile of comments. It needs to be choreographed, timed, sequenced, and aimed to move the work."
"Strong teams don't serve weak feedback."
"What's weak feedback? Vague, off target, or late stuff like make it pop or opinions with no owner or next step."
"Feedback is a lot like holding up a mirror. You're reflecting what's already working and like using a flashlight to hide in the corners."
"Giving feedback is a skill, just like design. It takes practice and care."
"We approached feedback loops like a system equal parts structure and skill. They have to reinforce one another."
"You can't do one without the other. Design the system, set rituals in the quality bar. They reinforce each other."
"Match the moment. Calibrate the altitude and the type of feedback to the context."
"Feedback is more like an investment and a contribution into not just the person's work, but also to their growth."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"You can’t jump from UX maturity rung one to six; it’s a deliberate climb focusing on your current challenge."
JJ KercherA Roadmap for Maturing Design in the Enterprise
June 15, 2018
"We use a holistic methodological approach combining explicit and implicit quantitative methods to fully get the user's perspective."
Daniela Magaña Flores Ariane Rahn Jeff Ephraim BanderAhead of Competition: Learn What UX Benchmarking Can Do for Your Business Today
March 10, 2022
"Google Sheets and Trello are our best friends — simple, flexible, and really powerful for managing research ops."
Saskia LiebenbergStart Small for Big Impact
May 15, 2019
"Protecting my time is something everyone is empathizing with right now."
Ariel KennanCivic Design in 2022
January 13, 2022
"Capabilities are the skills, mindsets, and professional abilities that underlie practices and then inform roles."
Peter MerholzThe Mysterious Case of the Missing UX Career Path
August 25, 2022
"Getting exact endorsement from the top helps your cause immensely."
Nathan CurtisBeyond the Toolkit: Spreading a System Across People & Products
June 9, 2016
"One superpower of ops humans is making problems and gaps visible to build awareness and drive change."
Saara Kamppari-MillerDesignOps for Inclusive Design and Accessibility
May 26, 2022
"Driver modeling tells you which research initiatives matter most based on their impact on key outcome metrics."
Landon BarnesAre My Research Findings Actually Meaningful?
March 10, 2022
"When I first came into the role, I almost took the consultant approach of writing a big report with recommendations, but that overwhelmed the team."
Dr Chloe SharpUsing Evidence and Collaboration for Setting and Defending Priorities
November 29, 2023
Latest Books All books
Dig deeper with the Rosenbot
Why do private sector innovation models often fail when applied directly to public sector organizations?
How does Mary Lynn view the impact of data-driven design practices on end users and designers?
How can organizations balance the pressure to deploy AI quickly with the need for thoughtful, resilient design?