Rosenverse

Log in or create a free Rosenverse account to watch this video.

Log in Create free account

100s of community videos are available to free members. Conference talks are generally available to Gold members.

Shadow Design–Where Else is Design Happening in Your Organization?
Thursday, April 20, 2023 • Enterprise Community
Share the love for this talk
Shadow Design–Where Else is Design Happening in Your Organization?
Speakers: Audrey Crane
Link:

Summary

Companies are spending millions of dollars on shadow design teams (aka non-designers doing design work). This session shares the concept and the tools we’ve used to measure how much shadow design is happening in a client’s organization. Plus, a case study with some surprising results, and how a design leader used it to grow her team after months of banging her head against a wall. An interesting and perhaps more productive way to approach the “ROI of Design” conversation.

Key Insights

  • Shadow design is prevalent in enterprises where non-designers perform significant design tasks due to scarcity of design resources.

  • The ROI argument for investing in design has become tired and often ineffective in convincing executives.

  • Measuring how much design work non-designers do can reveal substantial wasted effort, often equivalent to many full-time design roles.

  • Many people do not know how to effectively engage or collaborate with internal design teams, representing a solvable barrier.

  • Organizational design readiness varies widely, with most B2B companies stuck between ‘design aware’ and ‘design is just accepted without real investment.’

  • Even in teams with dedicated designers, product managers or engineers sometimes do design work when designers are overallocated or shifted elsewhere.

  • Shadow design teams often suffer from the Dunning-Kruger effect, where less skilled individuals overestimate their design abilities.

  • Democratization of design and research raises tensions about control and quality, requiring support systems to maintain standards.

  • Strategic design investments not only improve product quality but also increase engineering velocity by freeing engineers from design tasks.

  • A pragmatic approach to design advocacy is to show how current budgets are spent poorly rather than trying to justify ROI with abstract metrics.

Notable Quotes

"Predicting rain doesn’t count. Building an arc does."

"I’m sick of talking about the ROI of design. It just doesn’t work."

"The alternative to good design isn’t no design, it’s bad design."

"Shadow design is not about blaming people—it’s about recognizing that design work is happening outside the design team."

"The most alarming result is that people didn’t know how to work with the design team or get help from them."

"If your engineers are stretched, why not resource design better to increase overall velocity?"

"Dunning-Kruger effect in shadow design means people who know less are most confident about their design skills."

"Even teams with dedicated designers sometimes have gaps because designers get pulled to other priorities."

"It’s not naive to want metrics, but the ROI conversation is often code for fear and resistance to change."

"If you’re paying for design today but it’s done poorly by non-designers, wouldn’t you want to spend that money more effectively?"

Ask the Rosenbot
Jim Kalbach
Peace is waged with sticky notes: Mapping Real-World Experiences
2018 • Enterprise Experience 2018
Gold
Lada Gorlenko
Theme 1: Intro
2024 • Enterprise Experience 2020
Gold
Louis Rosenfeld
Coffee with Lou #3: What Makes for a Successful UX Conference Presentation?
2024 • Rosenfeld Community
JD Buckley
Communicating the ROI of UX within a large enterprise and out on the streets
2018 • Enterprise Experience 2018
Gold
Kristin Skinner
Theme 1 Intro
2021 • DesignOps Summit 2021
Gold
How to Identify and Increase your "Experience Quotient"
2018 • Enterprise Experience 2018
Gold
Sam Proulx
Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Screen Readers
2021 • Design at Scale 2021
Gold
Raven Veal
Dark Metrics: Illuminating the Negative Impact of Digital Health Design
2021 • Advancing Research 2021
Gold
Uday Gajendar
Theme Four Intro
2023 • Enterprise UX 2023
Gold
Samuel Proulx
Designing beyond caricatures: Embracing real, diverse user needs
2024 • Advancing Service Design 2024
Gold
Ariel Kennan
Theme 2 Intro
2021 • Civic Design 2021
Gold
Karen Pascoe
Developing Experience Teams and Talent in the Enterprise
2016 • Enterprise UX 2016
Gold
Kate Towsey
Ask Me Anything (AMA) with Kate Towsey
2025 • Rosenfeld Community
Sheri Byrne-Haber
Accessibility at Scale
2021 • Design at Scale 2021
Gold
Monty Hammontree
The Future of UX Research
2020 • Advancing Research Community
Sean McKay
Whole Product Thinking: Expanding beyond problem and solution space thinking
2024 • Rosenfeld Community

More Videos

Sam Proulx

"Low vision users often invert colors and use magnification levels as high as 400 percent to reduce eye strain."

Sam Proulx

SUS: A System Unusable for Twenty Percent of the Population

December 9, 2021

Michael Land

"Design Ops in government requires a lot of diplomacy – it’s about managing relationships and stakeholder expectations."

Michael Land

Establishing Design Operations in Government

February 18, 2021

Shipra Kayan

"I tried to do everything all by myself at first and it didn’t catch on because no one else knew I was doing it."

Shipra Kayan

How we Built a VoC (Voice of the Customer) Practice at Upwork from the Ground Up

September 30, 2021

Ian Swinson

"Communication matters—sending an email to an executive with spelling mistakes can ruin your respect."

Ian Swinson

Designing and Driving UX Careers

June 8, 2016

Isaac Heyveld

"The trusted partnership between the chief of staff and the executive is critically important."

Isaac Heyveld

Expand DesignOps Leadership as a Chief of Staff

September 8, 2022

Amy Evans

"Change is messy and it can be uncomfortable, much like baking bread—it’s hard to imagine sticky dough turning into a perfect loaf."

Amy Evans

How to Create Change

September 25, 2024

Kate Koch

"We’re powering a 300 plus organization of designers, researchers, program managers, and strategists."

Kate Koch Prateek Kalli

Flex Your Super Powers: When a Design Ops Team Scales to Power CX

September 30, 2021

Dave Gray

"People don’t share their beliefs; you have to search for and understand them to get true buy-in."

Dave Gray

Liminal Thinking: Sense-making for systems in large organizations

May 14, 2015

Matt Duignan

"We wanted a living network of knowledge so yesterday’s insight connects to today’s evidence and tomorrow’s learning."

Matt Duignan

Atomizing Research: Trend or Trap

March 30, 2020