Rosenverse

Log in or create a free Rosenverse account to watch this video.

Log in Create free account

100s of community videos are available to free members. Conference talks are generally available to Gold members.

Shadow Design–Where Else is Design Happening in Your Organization?
Thursday, April 20, 2023 • Enterprise Community
Share the love for this talk
Shadow Design–Where Else is Design Happening in Your Organization?
Speakers: Audrey Crane
Link:

Summary

Companies are spending millions of dollars on shadow design teams (aka non-designers doing design work). This session shares the concept and the tools we’ve used to measure how much shadow design is happening in a client’s organization. Plus, a case study with some surprising results, and how a design leader used it to grow her team after months of banging her head against a wall. An interesting and perhaps more productive way to approach the “ROI of Design” conversation.

Key Insights

  • Shadow design is prevalent in enterprises where non-designers perform significant design tasks due to scarcity of design resources.

  • The ROI argument for investing in design has become tired and often ineffective in convincing executives.

  • Measuring how much design work non-designers do can reveal substantial wasted effort, often equivalent to many full-time design roles.

  • Many people do not know how to effectively engage or collaborate with internal design teams, representing a solvable barrier.

  • Organizational design readiness varies widely, with most B2B companies stuck between ‘design aware’ and ‘design is just accepted without real investment.’

  • Even in teams with dedicated designers, product managers or engineers sometimes do design work when designers are overallocated or shifted elsewhere.

  • Shadow design teams often suffer from the Dunning-Kruger effect, where less skilled individuals overestimate their design abilities.

  • Democratization of design and research raises tensions about control and quality, requiring support systems to maintain standards.

  • Strategic design investments not only improve product quality but also increase engineering velocity by freeing engineers from design tasks.

  • A pragmatic approach to design advocacy is to show how current budgets are spent poorly rather than trying to justify ROI with abstract metrics.

Notable Quotes

"Predicting rain doesn’t count. Building an arc does."

"I’m sick of talking about the ROI of design. It just doesn’t work."

"The alternative to good design isn’t no design, it’s bad design."

"Shadow design is not about blaming people—it’s about recognizing that design work is happening outside the design team."

"The most alarming result is that people didn’t know how to work with the design team or get help from them."

"If your engineers are stretched, why not resource design better to increase overall velocity?"

"Dunning-Kruger effect in shadow design means people who know less are most confident about their design skills."

"Even teams with dedicated designers sometimes have gaps because designers get pulled to other priorities."

"It’s not naive to want metrics, but the ROI conversation is often code for fear and resistance to change."

"If you’re paying for design today but it’s done poorly by non-designers, wouldn’t you want to spend that money more effectively?"

Ask the Rosenbot
Sarah Williams
A Framework for CX Transformation
2021 • Design at Scale 2021
Gold
Mark Interrante
AI for Prioritization (3rd of 3 seminars)
2024 • Rosenfeld Community
Lada Gorlenko
Theme 2 Intro
2022 • Design at Scale 2022
Gold
Shipra Kayan
Emerging principles for using AI in Design: What the product design team at Miro has learned from deeply integrating AI in their workflow
2025 • Designing with AI 2025
Gold
Adam Thomas
Survival Metrics – Making Change in a Fast, Data-Informed, and Politically Safe Way
2022 • Design in Product 2022
Gold
Indi Young
Thinking styles: Mend hidden cracks in your market
2025 • Rosenfeld Community
Ryan Matthew
Bridging Design and Code: AI-Powered Design System Integration
2025 • Rosenfeld Community
Holly Cole
Understanding Experiences: When you have to do more than work
2018 • DesignOps Summit 2018
Gold
Trisha Terhar
Empathizing with the Empowered: Non-Researcher Responses to Democratization
2022 • Advancing Research 2022
Gold
JD Buckley
COMMUNICATE: Discussion
2018 • Enterprise Experience 2018
Gold
Rittika Basu
Age and Interfaces: Equipping Older Adults with Technological Tools
2023 • Advancing Research Community
Dave Hora
Advice for Establishing Research
2022 • Advancing Research Community
Indi Young
Paying Better Attention to the Problem with Indi Young
2019 • Advancing Research Community
Bria Alexander
Opening Remarks
2024 • Advancing Research 2021
Gold
Ryan Matthew
DesignOps without Boundaries: Building More with What You Have
2025 • DesignOps Summit 2025
Gold
Adam Cutler
Discussion
2016 • Enterprise UX 2016
Gold

More Videos

Laura Gatewood

"Make sure you clearly define who your message applies to so your audience can quickly scan and recognize relevance."

Laura Gatewood Laine Prokay

Beyond Buzzwords: Adding Heart to Effective Slack Communication

September 23, 2024

Nick Cochran

"Treat every conversation as an opportunity to make connections and learn meaningfully."

Nick Cochran

Growing in Enterprise Design through Making Connections

June 3, 2019

Alexia Cohen

"Federal funding does not provide food for participants, so we had to plan accordingly to make participation irresistible."

Alexia Cohen Adriane Ackerman

Increasing Health Equity and Improving the Service Experience for Under-Served Latine Communities in Arizona

December 4, 2024

Joshua Graves

"If something isn’t going the way it needs to, a little clarity can go a long way."

Joshua Graves

We Need To Talk: Addressing Unmet Expectations (Part 2 of 3)

April 28, 2025

Nora Tejeda

"When things get more complicated than expected, we re-negotiate scope or assign a full designer to keep quality."

Nora Tejeda Giovanna Alonso

Scaling Design Capabilities at BBVA Through a Self-service Design Model

June 10, 2021

Sofia Quintero

"Most teams want to build for 50, 100 people and migrate years of data instead of starting small."

Sofia Quintero

Beyond Tools: The Messy Business of Implementing Research Repositories

March 10, 2022

Christopher Geison

"Removing research from underneath UX has increased our ability to influence at Salesforce."

Christopher Geison

Theme 1 Intro

March 25, 2024

Alan Williams

"Benefits information really complex. Making them accessible is god's work in effect."

Alan Williams Rose Deeb

Designing essential financial services for those in need

February 10, 2022

Alla Weinberg

"The autonomic nervous system is 500 million years old and doesn’t know the difference between organizational change and a lion attack."

Alla Weinberg

People Are Sick of Change: Psychological Safety is the Cure

July 20, 2023